Was there a Greece or not in ancient and medieval times?
Matt Riggsby · Depends on what you mean by Greece. There was certainly a geographical region which was called Greece or the equivalent in various languages. Greece, as a place, was a thing people talked about and could point to on a map. There was also a Greek nation, in the sense of a people. Again, what they were called depended on what language you spoke, but certainly in antiquity there was a strong sense of people thinking they were Greeks/Hellenes based on language and association with certain items of culture like the Olympic games. This sense of nationhood declined somewhat during the Middle Ages (people in Greece identified themselves first and foremost as Romans but also understood that, secondarily, they might be distinguished from other Romans by language), but it never entirely went away. Greece as a nation-state, of course, did not. There weren’t nation-states at the time. That was a development of the modern world. Greece as the nation-state is the modern world’s ma...